• Mode-4 GPGPUs • NVIDIA - CUDA/OpenCL • AMD APP OpenCL • GPGPUs - OpenCL • GPGPUs : Power & Perf. • Home




hyPACK-2013 Mode-2 : GPU Comp. CUDA enabled NVIDIA GPU Prog.

NVIDIA's Compute Unified Device Architecture (CUDA) is a soft- ware platform for massively parallel high-performance computing on the company's powerful GPUs. NVIDIA's software CUDA Programming model automatically manages the threads and it is significantly differs from single threaded CPU code and to some extent even the parallel code. Efficient CUDA programs exploit both thread parallelism within a thread block and coarser block parallelism across thread blocks. Because only threads within the same block can cooperate via shared memory and thread synchronization, programmers must partition computation into multiple blocks.

An easy interface to determine the information such as to find mechanism for determining which devices (if any) are present and what capabilities each device supports is provided. First, to get count of how many CUDA devices in the system are built on CUDA Architectture call the API cudaGetDeviceCount(). After calling cudaGetDeviceCount(), then iterate through the devices and query relevant information about each device. The CUDA runtime returns device properties in a structure of type cudaDeviceProp. As of CUDA 3.0 & CUDA 4.0, the cudaDeviceProp structure contains the necessary information and most of the information in cudaDeviceProp is self explanatory and commonly used CUDA device properties.

struct cudaDeviceProp                     CUDA Device Properies

In all the programs, CUDA_SAFE_CALL() that surrounds CUDA API calls is a utility macro that we have provided as part of Hands-on codes. It simply detects that the call has retuned an error, prints the associated error message, and exists the appliation with ERROR FAILURE code.

List of Programs

Programs on Single GPU

Example 1.1 Write a CUDA program to compute Vector - Vector addition
Example 1.2 Write a CUDA program to compute Matrix - Matrix addition
Example 1.3
Write a CUDA Program to compute vector - Vector multiplication.
Example 1.4
Write a CUDA Program to find prefix sum of a given array.
Example 1.5 Write a CUDA program to find transpose of a matrix.
Example 1.6 Write a CUDA Program to calculate value of PI using numerical integration method.
Example 1.7 Write a CUDA Program to find infinity norm of a matrix.
Example 1.8
Write a CUDA Program for Matrix Vector multiplication
Example 1.9
Write a CUDA Program for Matrix Matrix multiplicationbased on tiling Partitioning
Example 1.10 Write a CUDA Program for implement solution of matrix system of linear equations Ax=b by Jacobi method.
Example 1.11 Write a CUDA program to implement the soluiton of Matrix system of Linear Equations AX=b by Conjugate Gradient method (Iterative Method).
Example 1.12 Write a CUDA program on sparse matrix multiplication of size n x n and vector of size n.(Assignment)

Programs on Multipe GPU

Example 1.13
Write a CUDA Program to compute vector - vector multiplication on Multi-GPU
Example 1.14
Write a CUDA Program for Matrix Matrix multiplication on Multi-GPU
Example 1.15
Write a CUDA Program for Vector Vector multiplication using CUBLAS Libraries on Multi-GPU
Example 1.16
Write a CUDA Program for Matrix Matrix multiplication using CUBLAS Libraries on Multi-GPU


CUDA Programs for Numerical Computaions


Makefile To Compile the program (Download source code : Makefile )

Example 1.1: Write a CUDA Program to Compute Vector Vector Addition based on global /shared memory.
(Download source code :
cuda-vector-vector-addition_GlobalMemory.cu )
cuda-vector-vector-addition_SharedMemory.cu )

  • Objective

    Write a CUDA Program to Compute Vector Vector Addition

  • Description

    The input vectors are generated on host-CPU and transfer the vectors to device-GPU for vector vector vector addition. A simple kernel based on the grid of thread blocks is generated in which thread is given a unique thread ID within its block. Each thread performs partial addition of two vectors and the final resultant value is generated on device-GPU and transfered to host-CPU.

  • Important Steps :
    Steps Description
    1. Memory allocation on host-CPU and device-GPU :
    Allocate memory for two input vectors and resultant vector on host-CPU & device-GPU
    Use cudaMalloc(void** array, int size)

    2. Input data Generation :
    Fill the input vector with single/double precision real values using randomized data as per input specification
    3. Transfer data from host-CPU to device-GPU:
    Transfer the host-CPU vector to device-GPU to perform computation
    Use cudaMemcpy((void*)device_array, (void*)host_array, size , cudaMemcpyHostToDevice )
    4. Launch Kernel :
    Define the dimensions for Grid and Block on host-CPU and launch the kernel for execution on device-GPU.
    Computation on device is performed for vector vector addition
    5. Transfer the result from device-GPU to host-CPU :
    Copy resultant vector to host-CPU from device-GPU.
    Use cudaMemcpy((void*)host_array, (void*)device_array, size , cudaMemcpyDeviceToHost)
    6. Check correctness of the result on host-CPU
    Compute vector-vector addition on host-CPU and Compare CPU & GPU results.
    7. Free the memory
    Free the memory of arrays allocated on host-CPU & device-GPU
    Use cudaFree(void* array)
  • Input
  • vector size

  • Output
  • execution time in seconds,Gflops achieved


Example 1.2: Write a CUDA Program to Compute Matrix Matrix Addition based on global /shared memory.
(Download source code :
cuda-matrix-matrix-addition.cu )

  • Objective

    Write a CUDA Program to compute Matrix Matrix Addition.

  • Description

    The input matices are generated on host-CPU and transfer the matrices to device-GPU to perform matrix matrix multiplication. A simple kernel based on the grid of thread blocks is generated in which thread is given a unique thread ID within its block. Each thread using its threadId performs addition using one element from each matrix and the final resultant value is generated on device-GPU and transfered to host-GPU.

  • Input
  • matrix size

  • Output
  • execution time in seconds,Gflops achieved


Example 1.3: Write a CUDA Program to Compute Vector Vector Multiplication based on global /shared memory.
(Download source code :
cuda-vector-vector-multiplication_GlobalMemory.cu )
cuda-vector-vector-multiplication_SharedMemory.cu )

  • Objective

    Write a CUDA Program to compute Vector Vector Multiplication.

  • Description

    The input vectors are generated on host-CPU and transfer the vectors to device-GPU for vector vector vector multiplication. A simple kernel based on the grid of thread blocks is generated in which thread is given a unique thread ID within its block. Each thread performs partial multiplication of two vectors and the final resultant value is generated on device-GPU and transfered to host-GPU.

  • Input
  • Vector Size

  • Output
  • execution time in seconds,Gflops achieved


Example 1.4: Write a CUDA Program to find prefix sum of an given array
(Download source code : cuda-prefix-sum.cu)    
  • Objective

    Write a CUDA program to find prefix sum of an given array.

  • Description

    This is simple program which computes prefix sum of an given array element. Prefix sum of an element of an array is defined by summation of all the element processed this element and the current element. The input array is generated on host-CPU and the Each thread performs summation of current element with previous element of an array. . The output array is generated on the device-GPU and transfer back to host-CPU

  • Input
  • Vector Size

  • Output
  • execution time in seconds,Gflops achieved


Example 1.5: Write CUDA a program to find transpose of a matrix.
(Download source code : cuda-transpose-matrix.cu    
  • Objective

    Write a program using CUDA to find out transpose of matrix.

  • Description

    The input matrix is generated on the Host-CPU and transfer to Device-GPU. A simple kernel function is written on GPU which generates the out-put matrix on the Device-GPU and transfer back to Host-CPU . The maxNumThread is used for computations.

  • Input
  • matrix size

  • Output
  • execution time in seconds


Example 1.6: Write a CUDA Program to calculate value of PI using numerical integration method
(Download source code : cuda-PI-computation.cu) )    
  • Objective

    Write a CUDA Program to calculate value of PI using numerical integration method.

  • Description

    This program computes the value of PI over a given interval using Numerical integration. The main thread distributes the given interval uniformly over the number of threads on CUDA device. Each thread calculates its part of the interval and finally thread 0 will add up all the value claculated by indivitual thread. Apart from the conventional threading model, in case of cuda program no lock mechanisim is used. In place of lock , every thread do its part of calculation and put the final result in a global array cell , which is allocated to this perticular thread only. After execution of each thread is over , thread 0 is assigned the job to gather all values and produce final result.

    The Grid of Thread Blocks and a unique thread ID is used to ditribute the required number of intervals for computation of PI value.

  • Input
  • Number intervals

  • Output
  • Value of PI


Example 1.7: Write a CUDA program to find infinity norm of a given Matrix
(Download source code : cuda-infinity-norm.cu )    
  • Objective

    Write a CUDA program to find infinity norm of given matrix.

  • Description

    Infinity Norm of a Matrix: The Row-Wise infinity norm of a matrix is defined to be the maximum of sums of absolute values of elements in a row, over all rows. After the initial validity checks, each thread is assigned a row using its id. If a thread completes its work, and if still there is some row to be operated, that will be assigned to this thread. The process continue till no row left to be operated. The thread 0 will find out maximum sum among all sum of all element of every row.

    The input matrix is generated on the Host-CPU and kernel is executed on Device-GPU in which Grid of thread blocks is used to accumulate the partial sum in an array. The infinity norm is computed using _synchreads()

  • Input
  • matrix size

  • Output
  • execution time in seconds,Gflops achieved


Example 1.8: Write a CUDA Program for Matrix Vector multiplication.
(Download source code : cuda-matrix-vector-multiplication.cu)    
  • Objective

    Write a CUDA Program to perform Matrix Vector multiplication.

  • Description

    Input matrix and the vector are generated on the Host-CPU. A simple kernel based on the grid of thread blocks is generated in which thread is given a unique thread ID within its block. Each thread reads one row of the matrix and performs computation with column of the vector to obtain resultant vector on Device-GPU. The resultant solution vector is transferred back to Host-CPU.

  • Input
  • Matrix Size

  • Output
  • execution time in seconds,Gflops achieved



Example 1.9: Write a CUDA Program for Matrix Matrix multiplication based on tiling (Shared Memory)
(Download source code : cuda-matrix-matrix-multiplication.cu)    
  • Objective

    Write a CUDA Program to perform Matrix Matrix multiplication.

  • Description

    Two input matrices are generated on the Host-CPU. In simple algorithm, the input matrix is partitoned as per Grid of thread blocks. In Global memory implementation,Each thread reads one row of the matrix and performs computation with one column of the another matrix and compute the correspodning elements of resultant marix on Device-GPU. The resultant matrix is transferred back to Host-CPU.While in local memory implementation, Matrices have been divided into BLOCKS of 16 x 16 sizes. One BLOCK loads one tile of both matrices from global memory to shared memory. Each thread with in BLOCK calculate temporal resultant in the local memory. After all threads within BLOCK completed their part of computation, the BLOCK stores the resultant tile into the global resultant matrix.

  • Input
  • Matrix Size

  • Output
  • execution time in seconds,Gflops achieved



Example 1.10: Write a CUDA Program for implement solution of matrix system of linear equations Ax=b by Jacobi method
(Download source code : cuda-jacobi.cu )    
  • Objective

    Write a CUBLAS CUDA program, for solving system of linear equations [A]{x} = {b} on CUDA enabled NVIDIA programming environment using Jacobi method

  • Description

    The Jacobi iterative method is one of the simplest iterative techniques to solve system of linear equations. The ith equation of a system of linear equations [A]{x}={b} is


    If all the diagonal elements of A are nonzero (or are made nonzero by permuting the rows and columns of A), we can rewrite equation (1)



    The Jacobi method starts with an initial guess x0 for the solution vector x. This initial vector x0 is used in the right-hand side of equation (2) to arrive at the next approximation x1 to the solution vector. The vector x1 is then used in the right hand side of equation (2), and the process continues until a close enough approximation to the actual solution is found. A typical iteration step in the Jacobi method is


    We now express the iteration step of equation 3 in terms of residual rk. Equation (3) can be rewritten as


    Each process computes n/p values of the vector x in each iteration. These values are gathered by all the processes and each process tests for convergence. If the values have been computed upto a certain accuracy the iterations are stopped otherwise the processes use these values in the next iterations to compute a new set of values.

  • Implementation The input matrix and the right hand-side vector, intial soultion vector is generated on Host-CPU and transferred to Device-GPU. In simple algorithm, the input matrix is partitoned as per Grid of thread blocks. Each thread reads one row of the matrix A and performs computation with vector and update the solution vector. Convergence of the solution is checked and the solution vector is transferred back to Host-CPU.

  • Input
  • Size of Input Matrix and the Vector

  • Output
  • The solution of matrix system of linear equations Ax = b


Example 1.10: Write a CUDA program to implement the solution of Matrix system of Linear Equations AX=b by Conjugate Gradient method (Iterative Method).
(Download source code : CudaConjugateGradient.cu)    
  • Objective

    CUDA implementaiton for Conjugate Gradient Method to solve the system of linear equations [A]{x}={b}. Assume that A is symmetric positive definite matrix.

  • Description

    Description of conjugate gradient method :

    The conjugate gradient (CG) method is an example of minimizing method. A real n x n matrix A is positive definite if xT A x > {0} for any n x 1 real, nonzero vector x. For a symmetric positive definite matrix A, the unique vector x that minimizes the quadratic functional

    f(x) = (1/2)xTAx-xTb 

    is the solution to the system Ax = b, here x and b are n x 1 vectors. It is not particularly relevant when n is very large, since the conjugating time for that number of iterations is usually prohibitive and the property does not hold in presence of rounding errors. The reason is that the gradient of functional f (x) is Ax - b, which is zero when f (x) is minimum. The gradient of a function is a n x 1 vector. We explain some important steps in the algorithm. An iteration of a minimization method is of the form

    xk+1 = xk  + taukdk     (1) 
     

    where tauk is a scalar step size and dkis the direction vector, dk is a descent direction for f at x.  We now consider the problem of determining tauk, given xk and dk, so that f(x) is minimized on the line x = xk + tauk dk, for tauk. The function f(xk+ tau dk) is quadratic in tau, and its minimization leads to the condition

    tau k =  gkTgk / dkTAdk ,    (2) 
    where gk=Axk - b is the gradient (residue)  vector after k iterations. The residual need not be computed explicitly in each iteration because it can be computed incrementally by using its value from the previous iteration. In the (k+1)th iteration, the residual gk+1 can be expressed as follows: 

         gk+1  = Axk+1 -        = A(xk+ tauk dk) - b 
         = Axk- b + tauk Ad 

         = gk + tauk Adk    
    (3)


    Thus, the only matrix-vector product computed in each iteration is Adk, which is already required to compute tauin the equation (2). If A is a symmetric positive definite matrix and d1, d2,..., dn are direction vectors that are conjugate with respect to A (that is, diT Adj=0 for all 0<n, j<=n, i!=j), then xk+1 in the Equation (1) converges to the solution of Ax = bin at most n iterations, assuming no rounding errors.

    In practice, however, the number of iterations that yields an acceptable approximation to the solution is much smaller than n.  It  also  makes the gradient at xk+1 orthogonal to search direction, i.e  dkT gk+1  = 0.  Now we suppose that the search directions are determined by an iteration of the form 

    dk+1 = -gk+1+ betak d     (4)

    where d0 = -g0  and beta0, beta1 , ...... remain to be determined. We find the new search direction in the  plane spanned by the gradient at the most recent point and previous search direction. The parameter betak+1is determined by following equation

    Betak+1 = gTk+1Adk/ dTkAdk     (5)
    And, one can derive orthogonality relations
      gTkg l= 0 (l != k);                 dTkAdl = 0 (l !=k)

    The derivation of the above equation (5)  and orthogonality relations is beyond the scope of this document. For details please refer [ ]. Using equation (3) and orthogonality relations, the equation (5)  can be further reduced to

    Betak+1 = gTk+1gk+1/ gTkgk<     (6)

    The above equations (1) to (6) lead to CG algorithm. The algorithm terminates when the square of the Euclidean vector norm of gradient (residual) falls below a predetermined tolerance value.  Although all of the versions of the conjugate gradient method obtained by combining the formulas for gk, Betak, and tauk in various ways are mathematically equivalent, their computer implementation is not. The following version is compared with respect to computational labor, storage requirements, and accuracy. The following sequence of steps are widely accepted.

    1. tau k         =  gkTgk / dkTAdk 
    2. xk+1        = xk  + tauk dk 
    3. gk+1        =  gk + tauk Ad 
    4. Betak+1 = gTk+1gk+1/ gTkgk 
    5. dk+1        = -gk+1 + Betak dk 

    where k = 0, 1, 2, .......... Initially we choose x0, calculate g0 = Ax0 - b , and put d0= -g0 

    The computer implementation of this algorithm is explained as follows :

    void CongugateGradient(float x0 [ ], float b [ ], float d) 
        { 
           float    g, Delta0, Delta1, beta; 
           float    temp, tau; 
           int        iteration;
           iteration = 0;
           x   = x0         g = b; 
           g = A x - g; 
           Delta0 = gT * g;   
           if ( Delta0 <= EPSILON) 
               return;  
           d = -g; 
           do { 
              iteration = iteration + 1; 
              temp = A * d;  
              tau = Delta0 / d * temp;  
              x = x + tau * d;  

              g = g + tau * temp;  
              Delta1 = g * g;
              if ( Delta1 <= EPSILON )  
                     break; 
              beta = Delta1 / Delta0;  
              Delta0 = Delta1;  
              d = -g + beta * d;  
          } while(Delta0 > EPSILON && Iteration < MAX_ITERATIONS);
           return;
     

    Regarding one-dimensional arrays of size n x 1 are required for temp, g, x, d. The storage requirement for matrix. A is depends upon the structure ( dense, band, sparse ) of the matrix.The two dimensional n x n array is the simplest structure to store matrix A. For large sparse matrix A this structure wastes a large amount of storage space, for such matrix A suitable storage scheme should be used.

  • The preconditioned conjugate gradient algorithm  


  • Let C be a positive definite matrix factored in the form C = E ET, and let the quadratic functional 

    f(x) = (1/2)xTAx - xTb + C
    We define second quadratic functional g(y) by the transformation y = ETx,

    g(x) = g(E-Ty) = (1/2)yTA*y - yTb * + C*         where A * = E-1AE-T, b* = E-1b, C* = C. 
    Here, A* is symmetric and positive definite. The similarity transformation

    E-TA*ET = E-TE-1A = C-1

    reveals that A* and A have same eigen values. If C can be found such that the condition number of the matrix A* is less than the condition number of the matrix A, then the rate of convergence of the preconditioned method is better than that of conjugate gradient method. We call C the preconditioning matrix, A* the preconditioned matrix, We assume that the matrix C = EET is positive definite, since E is nonsingular by assumption. If the coefficient matrix A has l distinct eigen values, the CG algorithm converges to the solution of the system Ax = b in at most l iterations (assuming no rounding errors). Therefore, if A has many distinct eigen values that vary widely in magnitude, the CG algorithm may require a large number of iterations to converge to an acceptable approximation to the solution.

    The speed of convergence of the CG algorithm can be increased by preconditioning A with the congruence transformation A* = E-1AE-T where E is a nonsingular matrix. E is chosen such that A* has fewer distinct eigen values than A. The CG algorithm is then used to solve A* y =b*, where x =(ET)-1y . The resulting algorithm is called the preconditioned conjugate gradient (PCG) algorithm. The step performed in each iteration of the preconditioned conjugate gradient algorithm are as follows

    1.   tau k         =  gkThk / dkTAdk 
    2.   xk+1       = xk + tauk dk 
    3.  gk+1       =  gk + tauk Ad 
    4.   hk+1       =  C-1gk+1 
    5. &nsbp; betak+1 = gTk+1hk+1/ gTkhk 
    6.   dk+1       = -hk+1 + betak+1dk


    where k = 0, 1, 2, .......... Initially we choose x0, calculate g0 = Ax0 - b, h0= C-1g0 and d0 = -h0. The multiplication by C-1 in step (4) is to be interpreted as solving a system of equations with coefficient matrix C. A source of preconditioning matrices is the class of stationary iterative methods for solving the system Ax* = b

  • Parallel implementations of the PCG algorithm
  • The parallel conjugate gradient algorithm involves the following  type of computations and communications

    Partitioning of a matrix : The matrix A is obtained by discretization of partial differential equations by finite element, or finite difference method. In such cases, the matrix is either sparse or banded. Consequently, the partition  of the matrix onto p processes play a vital role for performance. For, simplicity , we assume that A is symmetric positive definite and is rowwise block-striped partitioned. 


    Scalar Multiplication of a vector and addition of vectors :
    Each of these computations can be performed sequentially regardless of the preconditioner and the type of coefficient matrix. If all vectors are distributed identically among the processes, these steps require no communication in a parallel implementation.

    Vector inner products :
    In some situations, partial vectors are available on each  processes.  MPI Collective library calls are necessary to perform vector inner products  If the parallel computer supports fast reduction operations, such as optimized MPI, then the communication time for the inner-product calculations can be made minimum.

    Matrix-vector multiplication :
    The computation and the communication cost of the matrix-vector multiplication; depends on the structure of the matrix A. The parallel implementation of the PCG algorithm for three cases one in which A is a block-tridiagonal matrix of the type, two in which it is banded unstructured sparse matrix, and three in which the matrix is sparse give different performance on parallel computers. Various parts of the algorithm in each of the three cases dominate in terms of communication overheads.

    Solving the preconditioned system :
    The PCG algorithm solves system of linear equations in each iteration The preconditioner C is chosen so that solving the system modified system is in expensive compared to solving the original system of equations Ax = b. Nevertheless, preconditioning increases the amount of computation in each iteration. For good preconditioners, however, the increase is compensated by a reduction in the number of iterations required to achieve acceptable convergence. The computation and the communication requirements of this step depends on the type of preconditioner used. preconditioning method such as diagonal preconditioning, in which the preconditioning matrix C has nonzero elements only along the principle diagonal does not involve any communication Also, Incomplete Cholesky (IC) preconditioning, in which C is based on incomplete Cholesky factorization of A and it may involve different computations and communications in parallel implementation.

    The convergence of CG method iterations performed by checking the error criteria i.e. eulicidean norm of the residual vector should be less than prescribed tolerance. This convergence check involves gathering of real value from all processes, which may be very costly operation.

    We consider parallel implementations of the PCG algorithm using diagonal preconditioner for dense coefficient matrix type. As we will see, if C is a diagonal preconditioner, then solving the modified system does not require any interprocessor communication. Hence, the communication time in a CG iteration with diagonal preconditioning is the same as that in an iteration of the unpreconditioned algorithm.

    Thus the operations that involve any communication overheads are computation of inner products, matrix-vector multiplication and, in case of IC preconditioner solving the system.

  • Input

    Input Matrix and Right Hand side Vector

  • Output

    Solution x of linear system of matrix equations Ax = b

Example 1.12: Write a CUDA program on sparse matrix multiplication of size n x n and vector of size n.
(Download source code : SPmv_GPU.cu) || SPmv_cudpp.cu )
(Download Make File : Makefile-sparse )    
  • Objective

    To write a CUDA program on sparse matrix multiplication of size n x n and vector of size n.

  • Efficient storage format for sparse matrix

    Dense matrices are stored in the computer memory by using two-dimensional arrays. For example, a matrix with n rows and m columns, is stored using a n x m array of real numbers. However, using the same two-dimensional array to store sparse matrices has two very important drawbacks. First, since most of the entries in the sparse matrix are zero, this storage scheme wastes a lot of memory. Second, computations involving sparse matrices often need to operate only on the non-zero entries of the matrix. Use of dense storage format makes it harder to locate these non-zero entries. For these reasons sparse matrices are stored using different data structures. The Compressed Row Storage format (CRS) is a widely used scheme for storing sparse matrices. In the CRS format, a sparse matrix A with n rows having k non-zero entries is stored using three arrays: two integer arrays rowptr and colind, and one array of real entries values. The array rowptr is of size n+1, and the other two arrays are each of size k. The array colind stores the column indices of the non-zero entries in A, and the array values stores the corresponding non-zero entries. In particular, the array colind stores the column-indices of the first row followed by the column-indices of the second row followed by the column-indices of the third row, and so on. The array rowptr is used to determine where the storage of the different rows starts and ends in the array colind and values. In particular, the column-indices of row i are stored starting at colind [rowptr[i]] and ending at (but not including) colind [rowptr[i+1] ]. Similarly, the values of the non-zero entries of row i are stored at values [rowptr[i] ] and ending at (but not including) values [rowptr[i+1] ]. Also note that the number of non-zero entries of row i is simply rowptr[i+1]-rowptr[i].

  • Serial sparse matrix vector multiplication

    The following function performs a sparse matrix-vector multiplication [y]={A} {b} where the sparse matrix A is of size n x m, the vector b is of size m and the vector y is of size n. Note that the number of columns of A (i.e., m ) is not explicitly specified as part of the input unless it is required.

    void SerialSparseMatVec(int n, int *rowptr, int *colind, double *values
    double *b, double  *y)   

          int i, j, count ;  
          count = 0;
          for(i=0; i<n; i++)
          {
            y[i] = 0.0;
            for (j=rowptr[i]; j<rowptr[i+1];   j++)
              y[i] += value [count] * b [colind[j]];
            count ++;
          }
    }

  • Description of parallel algorithm

    In the parallel implementation, each thread picks a row from the matrix and multiplies it with the vector. Thus computation of all threads is carried out in parallel.

  • Implementation

    There are two implementations, one using CUDA kernels and the other using CUDPP library.

    CUDA implementation

    Step 1: The matrix size(no. of rows) and sparsity(percentage of non-zero) are provided by the user in the cmd line.

    Step 2: A sparse matrix and a vector of the given size are allocated and initialized. Also the row_ptr and col_idx vectors are created and assigned their appropriate based on the sparse matrix

    Step 3: The above vectors are also created and initialized on the device (GPU).

    Step 4: The sparse_matrix and vector are multiplied in the GPU to obtain the result.
    CUDPP implementation

    Steps 1 and 2 are same as above

    Step 3: Only two vectors are allocated on the device, the vector to be multiplied and a vector to store the result.

    Step 4: A sparse matrix object is created using CUDPPHandle (object pointer) and a CUDPPConfiguration (a structure containing the specifications of the algorithm, in this case sparse_matrix vector multiplication).

    Step 5: The multiplication of sparse matrix and vector are performed calling the CUDPP library procedure cudppSparseMatrixVectorMultiply() which perfroms the mulitiplication in the GPU.

  • CUDA API used:

    cudaMalloc(void** array, int size)       //allocates memory on device

    cudaFree(void* array )        //frees memory allocated on device

    cudaMemcpy((void*)device_array, (void*)host_array, size , cudaMemcpyHostToDevice )        //copies from host to device

    cudaMemcpy((void*)host_array, (void*)device_array, size , cudaMemcpyDeviceToHost )       //copies from device to host

  • CUDPP API used:

    cudppSparseMatrix(&sparseMatrixHandle, config, no_of_non_zero, no_of_rows, (void *) matrix, (unsigned int *) row_ptr, (unsigned int *)col_idx);
       //this fucntion creates a sparse matrix object assigned to the sparseMatrixHandle.

    cudppSparseMatrixVectorMultiply(sparseMatrixHandle, result, vector);     //performs the multiplication

  • Performance:

    The gettimeofday() function which is part of sys/time.h is used to measure the time taken for computation.

  • Input
  • The input to the problem is given as arguments in the command line. It should be given in the following format ; Suppose that the number of rows of the sparse matrix is n (only square matrices are considered) and the sparsity i.e. the percentage of number of zero's (given in the range 0 to 1) is m, then the program must be run as,

    ./program_name n m

    CPU generates the sparse matrix, the vector to be multiplied using random values and the row_ptr and col_idx vectors based on the sparse matrix.

  • Output
  • The CPU prints the time taken for the computation.



    Example 1.13: Write a CUDA Program to Compute Vector Vector Multiplication based on Multi-GPU.
    (Download source code :
    cuda-vector-vector-multiplication-mGPU.cu )

    • Objective

      Write a CUDA Program to compute Vector Vector Multiplication using multi-GPU

    • Description

      The input vectors are generated on host-CPU and transfer partial vector elements to each device-GPU for vector vector vector multiplication. A simple kernel based on the grid of thread blocks is generated in which thread is given a unique thread ID within its block. Each thread performs partial multiplication of two vectors on device-GPU and the accumulate the partial result on device-GPU and transfered to Host-CPU-GPU.

    • Input
    • Vector Size

    • Output
    • execution time in seconds,Gflops achieved


    Example 1.14: Write a CUDA Program for Matrix Matrix multiplication using Multi-GPU
    (Download source code : cuda-matrix-matrix-multiplication-mGPU.cu)    
    • Objective

      Write a CUDA Program to perform Matrix Matrix multiplication on multi-GPU

    • Description

      Two input matrices are generated on the Host-CPU and divided among multiple GPU-devices for computations. We create a two-dimensional grid that is overlaid on matrices. Matrices have been divided into thread blocks of 16 x 16 sizes. One BLOCK loads one tile of both matrices from global memory to shared memory. Each thread with in BLOCK calculate temporal resultant in the register. After all threads within block completed their part of computation, the BLOCK stores the resultant tile into the global resultant matrix. The resultant matrix is transferred back to Host-CPU. Timing has been recorded for the kernel launch using Cuda Events. Matrix Multiplication has been also computed on Host-CPU and after that both Host-CPU result and device-GPU result has been compared to check correctness of result.


    • Important Steps :
      Steps Description
      1. Memory allocation on host-CPU and device-GPU :
      Allocate memory for two input matrices and resultant matrix on host-CPU & device-GPU
      Use cudaMalloc(void** array, int size)

      2. Input data Generation :
      Fill the input matrices with single/double precision real values using randomized data as per input specification
      3. Transfer data from host-CPU to device-GPU:
      Transfer the host-CPU matrices to device-GPU to perform computation
      Use cudaMemcpy((void*)device_array, (void*)host_array, size , cudaMemcpyHostToDevice )
      4. Launch Kernel :
      Define the dimensions for Grid and Block on host-CPU and launch the kernel for execution on device-GPU.
      5. Transfer the result from device-GPU to host-CPU :
      Copy resultant matrix to host-CPU from device-GPU.
      Use cudaMemcpy((void*)host_array, (void*)device_array, size , cudaMemcpyDeviceToHost)
      6. Check correctness of the result on host-CPU
      Compute matrix-matrix multiplication on host-CPU; Compare CPU and GPU results.
      7. Free the memory
      Free the memory of arrays allocated on host-CPU & device-GPU
      Use cudaFree(void* array)
    • Input
    • Matrix Size

    • Output
    • execution time in seconds,Gflops achieved.



    Example 1.15: Write a CUDA Program for Vector Vector multiplication using CULBAS on Multi-GPU
    (Download source code : cuda-vector-vector-multiplication-cublas-mGPU.cu)    
    • Objective

      Write a CUDA Program to perform Vector Vector multiplication on multi-GPU

    • Description

      The input vectors are generated on host-CPU divided among multiple GPU-devices for computations. Transfer the vectors to available device_GPUs for vector multiplication using CUBLAS1 library call. The final output value is transferred back to Host-CPU.

      Computation on device is performed by CULBAS routines

    • Important Steps :
      Steps Description
      1. Memory allocation on host-CPU and device-GPU :
      Allocate memory for two input vectors on host-CPU & device-GPU
      Use cublasAlloc()

      2. Input data Generation :
      Fill the input vectors with single/double precision real values using randomized data as per input specification
      3. > Transfer data from host-CPU to device-GPU:
      Use cublasSetVector()

      4. Perform computation using cublasDdot() CUBLAS library call
      5. Transfer the result from device-GPU to host-CPU :

      6. Check correctness of the result on host-CPU
      Compute vector-vector multiplication on host-CPU; Compare CPU and GPU results.
      7. Free the memory
      Free the memory of arrays allocated on host-CPU & device-GPU

    • Input
    • Vector Size

    • Output
    • Execution time in seconds, Gflops acheived



    Example 1.16: Write a CUDA Program for Matrix Matrix multiplication using Multi-GPU
    (Download source code : cuda-matrix-matrix-multiplication-cublas-mgpu.cu)    
    • Objective

      Write a CUDA Program to perform Matrix Matrix multiplication on multi-GPU using CUBLAS Libraries

    • Description

      Two input matrices are generated on the Host-CPU In simple algorithm, the input matrix is partitoned as per Grid of thread blocks. Each thread reads one row of the matrix and performs computation with one column of the another matrix and compute the correspodning elements of resultant marix on device-GPU. The resultant matrix is transferred back to Host-CPU.

      We create a two-dimensional grid that is overlaid on matrices. Matrices have been divided into thread blocks of 16 x 16 sizes. One BLOCK loads one tile of both matrices from global memory to shared memory. Each thread with in BLOCK calculate temporal resultant in the register. After all threads within block completed their part of computation, the BLOCK stores the resultant tile into the global resultant matrix. The resultant matrix is transferred back to Host-CPU. Timing has been recorded for the kernel launch using Cuda Events. Matrix Multiplication has been also computed on Host-CPU and after that both Host-CPU result and device-GPU result has been compared to check correctness of result. Computation on device is performed for CULBAS routines

    • Important Steps :
      Steps Description
      1. Memory allocation on host-CPU and device-GPU :
      Allocate memory for two input matrices on host-CPU & device-GPU
      Use cublasAlloc()

      2. Input data Generation :
      Fill the input vectors with single/double precision real values using randomized data as per input specification
      3. Transfer data from host-CPU to device-GPU:
      Use cublasSetVector()

      4. Perform computation using cublasDgemm() CUBLAS library call
      5. Transfer the result from device-GPU to host-CPU :

      6. Check correctness of the result on host-CPU
      Compute matrix-matrix multiplication on host-CPU; Compare CPU and GPU results.
      7. Free the memory
      Free the memory of arrays allocated on host-CPU & device-GPU

    • Input
    • Matrix Size

    • Output
    • Execution time in seconds , Gflops acheived




    CUDA Device Structure
      struct cudaDevice Prop {
    char name[256];
    size_t totalGlobalMem;
    size_t sharedMemBlock;
    int regPerBlock;
    int warpSize;
    size_t memPitch;
    int maxThreadsPerBlock;
    int maxThreadsDim[1];
    int maxGridSize[3];
    size_t totalConstMem;
    int major;
    int minor;
    int clockRate;
    size_t texturealignment;
    int deviceOverlap;
    int multiProcessorcount;
    int KerneExecutionTimeoutEnabled;
    int integrated;
    int canMapHostMemory;
    int computeMode;
    int maxTexture1D;
    int maxTexture2d[2];
    int maxTexture3d[3];
    int maxTexture2dArray[3];
    int concurrentKernels;
      }



    CUDA Device Properties (Refer NVIDIA CUDA Programming Guide)
    Device Property Description
    char name [256]; An ASCII string indentifying the device [e.g., GeForce GTX 280"]
    size_t totalGlobalMem The amount of global memory on the devices in bytes
    size_t shareMemPerBlock The maximum amount of shared memory a single block may use in bytes
    int regsPerBlock The number of 32-bit registers available per block
    int warpSize The number of threads in a warp
    size_t memPitch The maximum pitch allowed for memory copies in bytes.
    int maxThreadsPerBlock The maxmum number of threads that a block may contain
    int maxThreadsDim[3] The number of blocks allowed along each dimneison of a grid
    size_t totalConstMem The amount of avialable constant memory
    int major The major revision of the device's compute capability
    int minor The minor revision of the device's compute capability
    Global Memory size : 1073741824
    size_t textureAlignment The device's requirement for texture alignment
    int deviceOverlap A bollean value representing whether the device can simultaneously perform a cudaMemcpy() and kernel execution
    int multiProcessorCount The number of multiprocessors on the device
    int kernelExecTimeoutEnabled A bollean value representing whether there is a runtime limit for kernels executed on this device
    int integrated A bollean value representing whether the device is an integrated GPI (i.e., part of the chipset and not a discrete GPU)
    int canMapHostMemory A bollean value repesenting whether the device can map host memory into the CUDA device addres space.
    int computeMode A vlaue representing the device's computing mode default, exclusive or, prohibited
    int maxTexture1D The maximum size supported for 1D textures
    int maxTextture2D[2] The maximum dimensions supported for 2D textures
    int maxTextture3D[3] The maximum dimensions supported for 3D textures
    int maxTextture2DArray[3] The maximum dimensions supported for 2D texture arrays
    int concurrentKernels A bollean value repesenting whether the device supports executing multiple kernels within the same context simultaneously.

    Centre for Development of Advanced Computing